COSTA MESA, Calif., July 28, 2016 /PRNewswire/ -- Mortgage servicers that invest strategically in the customer experience can not only recapture that investment, but also increase profits and raise customer satisfaction, according to the J.D. Power 2016 Primary Mortgage Servicer Satisfaction Study,℠ released today.
The study contradicts those in the mortgage servicing industry who believe customer experience investments are unnecessary and unprofitable. That perception can come from knowing that customers don't typically pick their mortgage servicer—48% of customers indicate they didn't, according to study findings—and that there are a lot of barriers to changing mortgage providers.
"Servicers with a captive audience can often view taking measurable steps that improve the customer experience as an unnecessary investment," said Craig Martin, senior director of the mortgage practice at J.D. Power. "They aren't against improving satisfaction, but cost containment is their top priority. The study clearly shows, however, that interacting with customers more efficiently—and more effectively—can reduce costs and increase profit for servicers regardless of the business model, while having the added bonus of improving satisfaction."
The study identifies four primary ROI benefits for servicers that invest in improving the customer experience:
Complaint reduction: Enabling customers to find answers to their own questions before making a call and resolving issues on the first contact reduce the number of repeated customer contacts and escalations, which can draw the attention of regulators and other agencies.
Cost containment and reduction: Eliminating the need for any contact and increasing the use of self-service channels can reduce customers' reliance on the live phone channel.
Limiting portfolio loss: Delivering a satisfying experience dramatically improves the chances customers will consider the lender for future mortgage needs, which protects against undesired attrition and supports future revenue growth by reducing acquisition costs.
Developing new business opportunities: Delivering a highly satisfying experience can promote increased cross-sell of existing customers or lead to more new business with partners.
Not surprisingly, customers experiencing a problem are highly likely to call their servicer (83%). But customers with a problem also increase the chance of public scrutiny, with 13% of such customers posting a comment on social media. Eliminating problems goes right to the bottom line by reducing call center costs and lowering the risk of receiving unwanted regulatory attention and its associated costs.
The study also finds that when servicers have an easy-to-navigate website with useful information, there is a substantial reduction in calls to live agents (from 42% to 30%). Just as important, customers want to use self-service options, with 40% saying they searched the servicer's website before calling, thereby spotlighting the missed opportunity to solve issues in the customer's preferred channel.
"Most servicers tend to focus on the complaints they receive, but the truly successful servicers get to the root causes of problems and take a more proactive approach," Martin said. "They realize better communication and self-service options can help their bottom line by reducing unnecessary calls."
There are business growth opportunities at stake, too. The study shows a clear link between satisfaction and customers' willingness to work with a firm in the future. When overall satisfaction is below 600 points (on a 1,000-point scale), 63% of customers indicate they would switch mortgage servicers in order to find better/improved customer service. Conversely, when overall satisfaction is above 900 points, 66% say they would "definitely will" refinance with their current servicer.
Further, the mortgage servicing experience can affect the broader relationship for companies that offer other products and services. When overall satisfaction is below 600 points, 27% of customers say their servicing experience triggered them to close or consider closing other accounts at their mortgage servicer company.
Quicken Loans ranks highest in the study with a score of 850, followed by Huntington National Bank with a score of 828. Regions Mortgage ranks third with a score of 810, an improvement of 77 points from 2015.
The 2016 U.S. Primary Mortgage Servicer Satisfaction Study measures customer satisfaction with the mortgage servicing experience in six factors: new customer orientation; billing and payment process; escrow account administration; interaction; mortgage fees; and communications. Satisfaction is calculated on a 1,000-point scale. It is based on responses from 7,542 customers who have had a mortgage on their primary residence for at least one year. The study was fielded in March through April 2016.
Overall Primary Mortgage Servicer
Satisfaction Index Scores
J.D. Power.com Power Circle Ratings
(Based on a 1,000-point scale)
Quicken Loans, Inc.
Huntington National Bank
TD Bank, N.A.
Caliber Home Loans
BB&T (Branch Banking & Trust & Co.)
Wells Fargo Home Mortgage
Central Mortgage Company
Fifth Third Mortgage
Bank of America
RoundPoint Mortgage Servicing
Freedom Mortgage Corp.
Ocwen Loan Servicing
USAA Federal Savings Bank*
*Not ranked because they do not meet the study award criteria.
Power Circle Ratings Legend 5 – Among the best 4 – Better than most 3 – About average 2 – The rest
Award-Eligible Mortgage Servicing Companies Included in the Study