Texas Supreme Court Decision Reaffirms Important Fundamental Workers' Comp Right

Jan 30, 2012, 17:35 ET from Texas Mutual Insurance Company

AUSTIN, Texas, Jan. 30, 2012 /PRNewswire/ -- In a decision that workers' compensation experts say is good for Texas employees and employers alike, the Supreme Court of Texas issued a unanimous opinion on January 27, 2012, that bars negligence claims against policyholders. The Port Elevator-Brownsville v. Casados case reversed a previous judgment from the Corpus Christi Court of Appeals and rendered judgment for Port Elevator. 

The Supreme Court upheld Texas' main legal tenet that employers cannot, intentionally or unintentionally, split their workforce to leave some employees uninsured. The court's opinion states that a key purpose of the rule against split workforces is that employees know whether they have the protections of workers' compensation coverage.

"This decision is great for Texas workers because it assures them that they will be covered, and it reinforces a longstanding workers' compensation rule," Mary Barrow Nichols, general counsel and senior vice president for Texas Mutual, said. "This straightforward ruling from the Texas Supreme Court is also positive for Texas employers, because it strengthens the exclusive remedy protection given to workers' compensation policyholders."

Previously, the court of appeals awarded nearly $3 million in damages to the family of a temporary worker who died on the job at Port Elevator. Texas Mutual provided workers' compensation insurance for Port Elevator, and the temporary staffing company had workers' compensation through another insurance company. The plaintiffs claimed that Port Elevator intended to and did exclude the worker from its workers' compensation coverage on various theories rejected by the court. The court held that an employee may have more than one employer, and each employer who has workers' compensation insurance is entitled to the exclusive remedy as a bar to claims about the injury.

Texas Mutual Insurance Company

Austin-based Texas Mutual Insurance Company is the state's leading provider of workers' compensation insurance, with approximately 33 percent of the market. Since 1991, the company has provided a stable, competitively priced source of workers' comp insurance for Texas employers. Helping employers prevent workplace accidents is a major part of Texas Mutual's mission. For more information, visit www.texasmutual.com.


Media Contact:
Elizabeth Christian
Levente Smith
Elizabeth Christian & Associates Public Relations
(512) 472-9599

SOURCE Texas Mutual Insurance Company