New research by MIT and Dana Farber shows how Wall Street-style financial engineering could make life-saving cancer drugs more available and affordable
Securitized consumer healthcare loans spread the cost of therapies over many years
Feb 24, 2016, 02:00 ET
CAMBRIDGE, Mass., Feb. 24, 2016 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- At a time when breakthrough therapies for certain types of cancers, hepatitis C, and rare diseases exist but remain out of reach for many patients due to their prohibitive cost, new research* by MIT Sloan Prof. Andrew W. Lo, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute's David Weinstock, MD, and MIT post-doctoral fellow Vahid Montazerhodjat offers a practical remedy: securitized consumer healthcare loans (HCLs). The team's research is published today in Science Translational Medicine.
HCLs, the equivalent of mortgages for large healthcare expenses, spread the cost of drugs and curative therapies over many years, making them more affordable to the people who need them. Financing HCLs through securitization—a financial engineering technique that involves pooling loans and converting them into securities—would allow more patients to have access to the drugs while generating attractive returns to investors.
"This is an instance where financial engineering could benefit the entire ecosystem," says Lo. "It helps patients by providing them with affordable access to therapeutic drugs and cures. It helps biopharmaceutical companies by enabling them to get paid back for the substantial investments in R&D they make to develop the therapies in the first place. And it helps insurance companies by linking payment to ongoing benefit."
Scientists have recently developed several breakthrough cures for diseases, but often the medicine's cost is stratospheric. Case in point: Glybera, a gene therapy that cures the highly rare disease lipoprotein lipase deficiency, was recently approved in Germany. Its price tag: nearly $1 million. The benefit from Glybera may last for the patient's remaining lifetime but the entire cost is paid upfront.
"The stark reality is that many patients don't have access to transformative therapies like Glybera solely due to affordability," says Weinstock. "This is a problem that will only grow as scientists create more cures. In the next five to seven years we could see cures for diseases like ALS, Duchenne muscular dystrophy, and many types of cancer, but those therapies could be too expensive for the average patient."
Securitized HCLs may also be profitable investments. Based on numerical simulations and statistical models, a large, diversified fund of HCLs generated hypothetical annual returns of 12%. For comparison, over the ten-year period from January 2006 to December 2015, the Standard & Poor's 500 Index saw a compound annual return of only of 7.3%.
"As an investment, securitized HCLs have another important advantage—they are not likely to be highly correlated with the stock market," says Lo. "This makes them even more attractive for investors such as pension funds, mutual funds, and life insurance companies."
Lo and his co-authors acknowledge that using financial engineering techniques in healthcare is not without risk—especially as securitization was chief among the techniques that precipitated the recent global financial crisis. While securitization is actively used in many markets today and plays a critical role in financing mortgages, student loans, and consumer credit, it can still be abused if proper protections, including regulatory oversight, are absent.
"But to argue that securitization is simply 'too risky' without a reasonable alternative is to relegate patients in desperate need to the status quo," says Lo. "Securitized HCLs make expensive breakthrough therapies more affordable right now. The science is here and it's moving at breakneck speed. Now we need the financial models to catch up."
* Vahid Montazerhodjat, David M. Weinstock, Andrew W. Lo. "Buying Cures vs. Renting Health: Financing Healthcare via Consumer Healthcare Loans." Science Translational Medicine 24 Feb. 2016. Print.
Logo - http://photos.prnewswire.com/prnh/20141117/158975LOGO
SOURCE MIT Sloan School of Management