Texas Supreme Court Affirms Resale Exemption for "Plush" Items

Mar 12, 2013, 12:30 ET from Ryan

DALLAS, March 12, 2013 /PRNewswire/ -- In a new decision styled Combs v. Roark Amusement & Vending, L.P., No. 11-0261 (Tex. – March 8, 2013), the Texas Supreme Court ("Court") has determined that the resale exemption applies to purchases of plush toys used in coin-operated amusement machines. This decision affirms an earlier decision of the Austin-based Third Court of Appeals. Click here to read the decision.

(Logo: http://photos.prnewswire.com/prnh/20110726/DA41187LOGO)

Roark Amusement & Vending, L.P. ("Roark") owns coin-operated amusement machines of the type commonly found in grocery stores, restaurants, and shopping malls. The machines consist of a glass tank filled with plush toys with a suspended mechanical claw. By inserting coins into these machines, customers may activate and control the claw to pick up and move a plush toy to a dispensing area from which successful customers receive toys.

Texas law exempts from sales and use tax tangible property or taxable services that will be resold as an integral part of a taxable service. Roark claimed this resale exemption on the purchase of plush toys to stock the machines.

Unlike amusement services generally, coin-operated amusement services are exempt from Texas sales and use tax. In addition, only customers who "win" the game will actually receive a plush toy. For these reasons, the Comptroller argued that Roark owed tax on the plush toys.

The Court firmly rejected the Comptroller's contentions. First, the Court agreed with Roark that coin-operated amusement services are "taxable" within the meaning of the resale exemption. It does not matter that such services are elsewhere exempted from the tax. Furthermore, the Court observed that the object of the game is to "win" a plush toy; otherwise, customers would not play. Therefore, the plush toys are personal property that is "integral" to the performance of the taxable service.

Roark Amusement & Vending is one of the most significant tax decisions to emerge from the Texas Supreme Court in recent years. It admonishes the Comptroller to avoid strained and unreasonable interpretations of tax exemptions. It expressly states that the courts (and the Comptroller) may not impose "extra-statutory" requirements and may not "[revise] the statute under the guise of interpreting it." Finally, it affirms the bedrock principle that "the Comptroller cannot through rulemaking impose taxes that are not due under the Tax Code…"

About Ryan
Ryan is an award-winning global tax services firm, with the largest indirect tax practice in North America and the sixth largest corporate tax practice in the United States. Headquartered in Dallas, Texas, the Firm provides a comprehensive range of state, local, federal, and international tax advisory and consulting services on a multi-jurisdictional basis, including audit defense, tax recovery, credits and incentives, tax process improvement and automation, tax appeals, tax compliance, and strategic planning. Ryan is a two-time recipient of the International Service Excellence Award from the Customer Service Institute of America (CSIA) for its commitment to world-class client service. Empowered by the dynamic myRyan work environment, which is widely recognized as the most innovative in the tax services industry, Ryan's multi-disciplinary team of more than 1,600 professionals and associates serves over 6,500 clients in 40 countries, including many of the world's most prominent Global 5000 companies. More information about Ryan can be found at www.ryan.com.


Damon Chronis

John Christian