To Protect or not to Protect Your No Claims Discount?

CHESTER, England, February 14, 2012 /PRNewswire/ --

• Not protecting your no claims discount (NCD) could see your premiums rise by 37 per cent if you make a claim
• Protecting a five year NCD will add £33 on average to your annual premium
• The longer you protect your NCD without claiming, the less valuable it becomes, warns MoneySupermarket.com

Drivers making a claim on their motor insurance policy, with an 'unprotected' no claims discount (NCD), could see the cost of their premiums increase by around 37 per cent, according to research by MoneySupermarket.com.

The UK's leading price comparison site investigated the cost of protecting or not protecting your NCD for a standard scenario. The research reveals if a policy holder who had five years 'unprotected' NCD made a claim they would see premiums hiked from £349 to £479*, an increase of £130, or 37 per cent. However, motorists with five years protected NCD making a claim would only see a three per cent increase, or £10 - from £382 to £392 - to the cost of their annual premium.^[1]

Pete Harrison, car insurance expert at MoneySupermarket.com, said: "Building up your no claims discount over a number of years, can be a valuable commodity and can significantly reduce the cost of your premiums.

"Having reached the five year no claims discount level, many motorists will be reluctant to take the risk of losing it and may consider paying extra to protect it. With premiums on average rising by 37 per cent if you make a claim, paying extra to protect your policy against this sharp hike might be worthwhile. But be warned, if you protect your policy but don't make a claim for a number of years, you could find that you are eroding any potential savings."

TIPPING POINT: PROTECTED NCD vs UNPROTECTED NCD

Motorists looking to 'protect' a five year no claims discount (NCD) will pay an extra £33 on average on top of the cost of their annual car cover, however this varies significantly between providers.^[1]

The longer a motorist protects their NCD and doesn't make a claim, the less cost-effective it becomes. For example, in the first year, a motorist who protects their five years NCD, and makes a claim will be £54 better off on average, compared with a motorist who made a claim on an unprotected policy. However, because of the £33 annual cost to protect your NCD, if you haven't claimed until the second year, you will be £21 better off.

The tipping point comes in the third year; if you finally make a claim, you will have paid £12 more compared with someone who didn't protect their NCD and claimed^[2], and in the fourth year, you will have paid £45 more.

Pete Harrison said: "If you are looking to protect your no claims discount, shop around for the best deal available for your circumstances. MoneySupermarket can help you save £400 on your car insurance** and if you do find a better deal with another provider, you can take your no claims bonus with you.

"It's crucial for motorists to understand the additional fees for protecting a no claims discount depends on your personal circumstances and motoring history, as well as the provider. Furthermore, it's worth motorists remembering it is the discount they are paying to protect, not their premium - so if you do make a claim, it may well increase the amount you pay for your cover anyway."

The research also reveals there are vast differences in the small print between motor insurance providers for protecting a NCD; some providers will allow multiple claims on protected policies without penalty. In addition motorists will not lose their entire NCD if it is not protected and they make a claim - generally they would lose two years NCD*.

Notes to editors:

*Typically making a claim on a car insurance policy when there is no protection in place causes the driver to lose two years of no claims history. This means someone who makes a claim with 5 years no claims will be treated as someone with 3 years of no claims when they come to the end of their policy.

** Based on online independent research by Consumer Intelligence during 01 January 2012 to 31 January 2012. 25 % of consumers could achieve a saving of £490.98 with MoneySupermarket (exc Legal) Motor Insurance

^[1]Motor insurance premiums:

(Standard motor insurance scenario)

                          1           2           3          4          5
                                  5 Yr NCD    5 Yr NCD
                      5 Yr NCD - (Protected) (Protected) 3 Yr NCD  Zero Years
        Provider       0 Claim    - 0 Claim   - 1 Claim  - 1 Claim     NCD
    Endsleigh         GBP272.75   GBP313.67   GBP397.26  GBP352.98   GBP641.78
    The Policy Shop   GBP297.65   GBP319.59   GBP319.59  GBP452.20 GBP1,184.48
    Aim               GBP307.57   GBP331.98   GBP377.03  GBP470.57   GBP956.35
    Quotemehappy.com  GBP319.94   GBP348.20   GBP348.20  GBP409.94   GBP857.47
    motorquote direct GBP322.41   GBP348.21   GBP348.21  GBP470.15 GBP1,007.24
    quotelinedirect   GBP323.35   GBP346.80   GBP346.80  GBP475.45 GBP1,183.04
    Auto Direct       GBP323.43   GBP350.37   GBP350.37  GBP493.40 GBP1,123.75
    AXA               GBP324.73   GBP373.44   GBP373.44  GBP419.30   GBP737.50
    insure.co.uk      GBP325.43   GBP351.47   GBP351.47  GBP431.37   GBP823.86
    LV=               GBP329.38   GBP362.09   GBP362.09  GBP399.09   GBP607.50
    Hastings Direct   GBP330.78   GBP357.25   GBP357.25  GBP431.32   GBP823.78
    Nationwide        GBP359.20   GBP393.55   GBP393.55  GBP432.40   GBP651.23
    ASDA              GBP362.05   GBP391.00   GBP391.00  GBP551.42 GBP1,316.27
    Express Insurance GBP362.74   GBP389.95   GBP439.00  GBP541.86 GBP1,431.78
    The AA            GBP369.03   GBP384.85   GBP393.15  GBP507.14   GBP966.17
    Santander         GBP377.71   GBP434.37   GBP434.37  GBP500.46 GBP1,832.27
    Swiftcover        GBP382.93   GBP444.58   GBP444.58  GBP511.94   GBP755.94
    Churchill         GBP391.14   GBP448.38   GBP448.38  GBP490.78   GBP749.42
    Privilege         GBP412.34   GBP452.62   GBP452.62  GBP518.34   GBP789.70
    Swinton           GBP415.83   GBP444.07   GBP455.57  GBP605.30 GBP1,172.04
    American Express  GBP424.61   GBP442.50   GBP451.94  GBP598.77   GBP974.67
    Average           GBP349.29   GBP382.33   GBP392.18  GBP479.25   GBP980.30

                                           Difference
                                         between having
    Extra if protected Extra if you were    protected
     but you crash (2  not protected (1   yourself and
          Vs 3)              Vs 4)        not (1 Vs 2)
         GBP83.59          GBP80.23         GBP40.92
         GBP0.00           GBP154.55        GBP21.94
         GBP45.05          GBP163.00        GBP24.41
         GBP0.00           GBP90.00         GBP28.26
         GBP0.00           GBP147.74        GBP25.80
         GBP0.00           GBP152.10        GBP23.45
         GBP0.00           GBP169.97        GBP26.94
         GBP0.00           GBP94.57         GBP48.71
         GBP0.00           GBP105.94        GBP26.04
         GBP0.00           GBP69.71         GBP32.71
         GBP0.00           GBP100.54        GBP26.47
         GBP0.00           GBP73.20         GBP34.35
         GBP0.00           GBP189.37        GBP28.95
         GBP49.05          GBP179.12        GBP27.21
         GBP8.30           GBP138.11        GBP15.82
         GBP0.00           GBP122.75        GBP56.66
         GBP0.00           GBP129.01        GBP61.65
         GBP0.00           GBP99.64         GBP57.24
         GBP0.00           GBP106.00        GBP40.28
         GBP11.50          GBP189.47        GBP28.24
         GBP9.44           GBP174.16        GBP17.89
         GBP9.85           GBP129.96        GBP33.04

Sourced by http://www.moneysupermarket.com 26.01.2012

^[2]Motor insurance premiums - making a claim on protected vs. unprotected

(Standard motor insurance scenario)

• £479.25 (unprotected premium) - £392.18 (protected premium) = £87.07 or £87
• In the first year £87.07 - £33.04 (extra cost of protecting NCD) = £54.03 or £54 better off
• In the second year: £54.03 - £33.04 = £20.99 or £21 better off
• In the third year: £20.99 - £33.04 =  - £12.05 or £12 worse off
• In the fourth year: - £12.05 - £33.04 =  - £45.09 or £45 worse off

MoneySupermarket.com's customer commitment

• No other site compares more prices or products
• We are independent so only find the best deals for you   
• The price you see is the price you pay - you don't need to go direct and you won't get a better deal doing so   
• Your details are safe with us and we won't sell them to anybody

MoneySupermarket.com compares (at 31^st January 2012)

• 93 car insurance providers and 78 home insurance providers
• 11 broadband providers and 16 energy providers   
• 30 unsecured loan and 5 secured loan providers
• 63 mortgage lenders and 27 credit card providers
• 68 savings providers and 36 current account providers.
• Over 1,000,000 mobile phone deals

We promise to be clear and impartial

• All the products in our full search results tables are displayed in a completely unbiased manner.
• We don't add fees or commissions on to the prices we compare.
• There may be times when another site compares more companies than us on a particular product, perhaps because of market changes or technical issues. You'll be able to see this and know we are working hard to fix it.

We promise to be trustworthy

• We never use your data to make unwanted sales calls or send you spam.
• We never pass your personal information to third parties unless you give us permission to do so.
• Even if you choose to receive additional information from us, you can opt out at any time. 
• We promise to be supportive.
• You can use our community forum to get information and help from other customers.

If you need further help or support, you can contact our sales advisors or customer services agents.

For further information, please contact: 

Nicki Parry
PR Officer
+44(0)1244-370318
[email protected]

SOURCE moneysupermarket.com